Surfside Real Estate Market Trends: Analyzing Oceanfront Condos After the Tower Collapse

On Thursday, June 24th, 2021, the tragic collapse of the 13-story Champlain Towers South building in Surfside, Florida, shocked the world. More than two months after this devastating event, Big Data Realty has analyzed local real estate data to understand exactly how this tragedy has impacted the Surfside oceanfront condo market. Whether you are a buyer looking for opportunities or an owner considering a sale, understanding these changing market conditions is crucial.

Discover the Surfside Community Surfside is a picturesque beachfront town in Miami-Dade County, ideally situated just north of Miami Beach and south of Bal Harbour. Spanning just 1 square mile, this intimate city is home to roughly 5,600 residents, boasting a vibrant, diverse demographic where half the population speaks Spanish and over 2,500 residents are part of a strong Jewish community. Families are highly attracted to Surfside due to its top-tier Miami-Dade County public schools, including the 10/10 rated Ruth K. Broad/Bay Harbor K-8 Center, Miami Beach Nautilus Middle School, and Miami Beach Senior High. The area’s exclusivity has also drawn high-profile residents, such as Ivanka Trump, Jared Kushner, and international celebrities like Russian singer Valery Leontiev.

If you want to learn more about the incredible lifestyle and amenities this area has to offer, be sure to check out our deep-dive community video series on our YouTube channel!

Historical Development and Pricing by Decade Surfside currently features 26 residential oceanfront buildings encompassing almost 2,000 units. To fully grasp the market’s response to the collapse, it helps to look at the properties based on when they were built:

• The 1960s & 1970s: This era marked Surfside’s initial real estate boom with buildings like the Carlisle, Spaiggia, Four Winds, 9500 Ocean, and Manatee. Typically featuring 900-1,100 sq ft apartments, recent sales historically ranged from $300,000 to $600,000. Following the tower collapse, inventory in this older segment increased, but asking prices have surprisingly remained stable without significant reductions.
• The 1980s: Only three towers were built in the 80s: Marbella and the tragically fated Champlain South and North towers. Before the disaster, 2-3 bedroom units were selling for $500,000 to $1 million. Unsurprisingly, this segment is the most severely impacted today; there has been absolutely no activity, with zero sales or pending listings recorded in the two months post-collapse.
• The 1990s: Featuring buildings like Champlain East, Waves, Mirage, and Rimini, most of these structures were built under stricter building codes implemented after Hurricane Andrew in 1992. Units historically sold for $500,000 to $1.5 million. Today, this segment remains relatively stable, with average asking prices holding around $1.2 million and steady inventory levels.
• 2000 to 2010: The shift toward lower-density luxury living began with the Solimar, Waverly, and Azure buildings. Prices here ranged broadly from $550,000 to $2.35 million. Post-collapse, inventory has almost doubled in this sector, yet average asking prices have actually increased slightly to $1.3 million.
• 2010 to Present (Ultra-Luxury): The newest developments, including Ocean 7, Fendi Chateau, Surf Club Four Seasons, and Arte, represent the pinnacle of Miami luxury. Prices in these highly exclusive buildings range from $4 million to upwards of $22.5 million. Following the collapse, average asking prices here dropped by roughly 12% (down to $12.6 million), and there were no MLS-recorded sales in the initial two months following the tragedy, pointing to high-end buyer caution.

Post-Collapse Market Impact The most noticeable shift in the Surfside real estate market is a sharp decline in sales volume. In the two months leading up to the collapse, 30 sales were closed; in the two months following the tragedy, only 12 sales occurred. Furthermore, buyers have grown cautious of expensive older oceanfront properties, with the highest post-collapse sale capping at just $1.5 million.

Overall, inventory has seen a small increase across most segments. However, outside of the ultra-luxury market (buildings constructed in the last 10 years), average asking prices have generally gone up rather than down.

Looking Ahead It remains to be seen how long buyers will exercise this level of caution regarding oceanfront condos. At Big Data Realty, we utilize proprietary big data monitoring tools to track these shifting market conditions in real time, helping buyers secure the best deals and assisting sellers in pricing their properties optimally.

Click to expand

For the most up-to-date information on South Florida real estate, make sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel, watch our community video series, and visit our website to sign up for our professional real estate services.